Sister cells carrying a fluorescently tagged protein are imaged just after division
PHYSICS · Multi-part · Fermi University Physics · Scientific Practice & Experimental Methods · Biophysics & Medical Physics · Data analysis and model fitting in the laboratory
Forces, Machines and Signals, Ch Numbers and noise in a small system
Problem
Sister cells carrying a fluorescently tagged protein are imaged just after division, and the pairs are binned by total intensity I1+I2. The bin means, as (total intensity, mean of (I1−I2)2) in arbitrary units, are (400,1050), (800,1930), (1200,3080), (1600,3950), (2000,5100), (2400,5920).
((a)) Fit a line through the origin to find the fluorescence per molecule ν.
((b)) A second laboratory images the same strain some minutes after division, so that each daughter has made new copies. Take a parent with N copies and consider two idealised cases: (i) each daughter independently makes a Poisson number of new copies with mean μ; (ii) each daughter makes exactly m new copies. For each case find ⟨(I1−I2)2⟩ in terms of the mean total intensity, and say what a line forced through the origin would report for ν.
((c)) In case (ii), with the true ν from (a) and m=100, a bin sits at total intensity 1200. What fraction of ν is the ratio ⟨(I1−I2)2⟩/(I1+I2) in that bin, and what feature of the plot would warn the second laboratory?