Someone argues: "The amplitude equations for a pumped oscillator without damping give…
PHYSICS · Subjective · Fermi University Physics · Mechanics & Dynamical Systems · Nonlinear dynamics and chaos · Nonlinear dynamics and chaos
Modes, Packets and Media, Ch Driven and pumped nonlinear oscillators and the route to chaos
Problem
Someone argues: "The amplitude equations for a pumped oscillator without damping give a growth rate s=21(hω0/2)2−ν2. At exact tuning (ν=0) this is s=hω0/4, which is positive for any h>0. So the rest state is unstable for any nonzero modulation depth, and a pendulum with Q=200 shaken at twice its natural frequency will start swinging however small the shaking amplitude is." Find the error in this argument, and give the correct threshold modulation depth hc for Q=200.