PHYSICS · Multi-part · Fermi University Physics · Particle Physics & Quantum Fields · Interacting fields, Feynman diagrams and QED · Interacting fields, Feynman diagrams and QED
Particle Physics, Ch Exchange, range and coupling: diagrams as bookkeeping
Problem
Two quarks scatter off each other, once by exchanging a photon and once by exchanging a W boson, at the same momentum transfer Δp=50MeV/c. Take the W mass as MW=80.37GeV/c2, the weak coupling as αW≈1/30 and the electromagnetic coupling as α≈1/137, so that (αW/α)2≈21.
((a)) Estimate the factor by which the amplitude for W exchange is suppressed relative to photon exchange, from the mass of the exchanged quantum alone.
((b)) Hence estimate the factor by which the W-exchange rate is suppressed relative to the photon-exchange rate, for two quarks with the same couplings.
((c)) Now include the actual coupling ratio (αW/α)2≈21 and give an order-of-magnitude estimate for how much rarer virtual W exchange is than virtual photon exchange between two quarks at this momentum transfer.