Someone argues: "A rotating rigid body carries the full rigid-body moment of inertia…
PHYSICS · Multi-part · Fermi University Physics · Nuclear Physics · The nuclear force and nuclear models · The nuclear force and nuclear models
The Nucleus Resolved, Ch Collective motion: the deformed nucleus, vibrations, rotations and giant resonances
Problem
Someone argues: "A rotating rigid body carries the full rigid-body moment of inertia Irigid because every part of it is locked to every other part. Pairing locks nucleons together into strongly correlated J=0 pairs, an even tighter binding than an ordinary rigid solid. So pairing ought to push the measured I of a rotating deformed nucleus above Irigid, not below it; the measured values with I<Irigid (for example I≈0.53Irigid in the 238U ground band) must have some cause other than pairing."
((a)) Find the error in this argument.
((b)) Give the correct qualitative reason pairing lowers the measured I below Irigid, and say what backbending at high spin shows about this mechanism.