Stress, Strain & Hooke's Law for Solids

In 1676, Robert Hooke published one of the most important discoveries in physics as a scrambled anagram: ceiiinosssttuv. He was staking his claim while keeping the secret from rivals. Two years later he unscrambled it: ut tensio, sic vis — "as the extension, so the force." Stretch something twice as hard and it stretches twice as far. You have already met this law wearing its spring costume, F=−kxF = -kx. But the spring version hides a puzzle: a long spring stretches more than a short one, a thick wire less than a thin one — so kk is a property of the object, not the material. Is steel stiff, or is a steel part stiff? This chapter's opening move is to strip the geometry away. Divide the force by the cross-sectional area it acts on and you get stress — the loading the material itself feels. Divide the extension by the original length and you get strain — the fractional deformation, a pure number. Written in these per-unit variables, Hooke's law becomes a statement about materials: stress is proportional to strain, with a proportionality constant that is the same for a paper clip and a suspension-bridge cable, as long as both are steel. That is the material-science view, and it is exam gold: CBSE and ISC ask for the definitions and the stress–strain curve; JEE and NEET turn the curve's labelled points into MCQs every year. Master the two definitions and one graph here, and the whole elasticity unit becomes bookkeeping.

Key takeaways
  • Stress σ=F/A\sigma = F/A is the internal restoring force per unit cross-sectional area (unit: Pa = N/m²); strain ε=ΔL/L\varepsilon = \Delta L/L is the fractional deformation (no units).
  • Three loading styles: tensile/compressive (normal stress, length changes), shear (tangential stress, shape changes), and hydraulic/volume (pressure on all sides, volume changes).
  • Hooke's law for solids: within the proportional limit, σ=E ε\sigma = E\,\varepsilon — stress ∝ strain, with modulus EE a property of the material, not the object.
  • The spring constant of a rod or wire follows from the material law: k=YALk = \dfrac{YA}{L} — thick and short means stiff; long and thin means soft.
  • The stress–strain curve is the material's fingerprint: proportional limit → elastic limit (yield) → plastic region → ultimate strength → fracture.
  • Key idea: stress and strain are force and deformation with the geometry divided out — so Hooke's law becomes a law about materials.
The core insight

Within the elastic limit, the stress developed in a solid is directly proportional to the strain produced (σ=Eε\sigma = E\varepsilon); stress and strain strip the object's geometry out of force and extension, making the proportionality constant a pure material property.

Where this lives today

Every certified batch of structural steel, aircraft aluminium, or surgical-implant titanium ships with a tensile test report — a stress–strain curve drawn by a machine that stretches a standard sample to destruction, exactly as this article describes. Design codes then command engineers to keep working stresses a safety factor below yield: typically a third of yield stress for buildings, stricter for lifts and pressure vessels. The 2010s-to-2020s materials headline is at the nano end: graphene's Young's modulus of about 1 TPa — five times steel's — was measured by pressing an atomic-force-microscope tip into a suspended one-atom-thick sheet and reading its stress–strain response, elasticity's oldest experiment re-run on the thinnest possible sample. And metallurgists deliberately use the plastic region this article warns you away from: car crumple zones are engineered to deform plastically, spending crash energy as the metal yields — the stress–strain curve's area put to work saving lives.

The physical picture

Why does a solid resist stretching at all? Zoom in. A crystalline solid is a lattice of atoms held at preferred spacings by interatomic forces. Pull the lattice and every bond stretches slightly; each bond pulls back like a microscopic spring. Push, and the bonds compress and push back. A solid is Avogadro's number of tiny springs in a 3-D mesh — which is exactly why the macroscopic behaviour ends up looking like Hooke's spring law, and why it stops looking like it when you pull hard enough for atoms to start sliding past each other and re-bonding elsewhere (that is plastic deformation — the paper clip that stays bent).

Figure
A loaded rod, and the atomic bond-springs that resist — stress and strain defined
F L ΔL area A stress σ = F/A strain ε = ΔL/L pull every interatomic bond is a tiny spring: stretch them all a little → elastic (reversible) make atoms slip past each other → plastic (permanent) One material law behind every object-level spring constant

Now the two definitions that carry the whole chapter, and the physical reason each is built the way it is.

Stress spreads the force over the area that carries it. Hang a 10 kg mass from a steel wire of cross-section 1 mm21\ \mathrm{mm^2} and every square millimetre of that cross-section carries the full 98 N. Hang it from a wire of 2 mm22\ \mathrm{mm^2} and each unit of area carries half as much — the material is working half as hard even though the force is identical. Think of lanes on a highway: the same traffic across more lanes means less congestion per lane. What decides whether the wire deforms — or breaks — is the load per lane, not the total load. Strictly, stress is defined through the internal restoring force the deformed material develops across the section; in equilibrium that internal force equals the applied one, which is why we compute it as applied force over area.

Strain compares the deformation to the original size. A 1 mm extension is an enormous deformation for a 10 cm sample and a negligible one for a 100 m cable. Dividing ΔL\Delta L by LL produces a fair, size-free measure: both the lab wire and the bridge cable at ε=10−3\varepsilon = 10^{-3} are in the same mechanical state, every bond stretched by the same fraction. That is why strain — a pure, unitless number — is the honest x-axis of material behaviour. And the three ways to load a solid, which you must be able to tell apart on sight: pull or push along the axis (tensile/compressive — length changes), slide the top face relative to the bottom like pushing a book sideways (shear — shape changes, angles tilt), or squeeze uniformly from all directions as fluid pressure does (hydraulic/volume — volume shrinks). Each style gets its own stress, its own strain, and — next article — its own modulus.

The math: three stresses, three strains, one law

The normal (tensile or compressive) stress answers: how hard is each unit of cross-section being pulled? For a force FF applied perpendicular to a section of area AA,

σ=FA(1)\sigma = \frac{F}{A} \qquad (1)

where: σ\sigma — normal stress, in pascals (1 Pa=1 N/m21\ \mathrm{Pa} = 1\ \mathrm{N/m^2}); FF — the magnitude of the deforming force normal to the section; AA — the cross-sectional area carrying it. The pascal is tiny — real steel stresses run in megapascals (10610^6 Pa) and moduli in gigapascals (10910^9 Pa). Same unit as pressure, different job: pressure in a fluid pushes on external surfaces from all sides; stress lives inside a solid and has a direction and a style (tensile, compressive, shear). The matching deformation measure is the longitudinal strain. A rod of natural length LL that extends by ΔL\Delta L has

ε=ΔLL(2)\varepsilon = \frac{\Delta L}{L} \qquad (2)

where: ε\varepsilon — longitudinal strain, dimensionless (often quoted as a percentage: ε=0.002\varepsilon = 0.002 is "0.2% strain"); ΔL\Delta L — the change in length; LL — the original length. Typical exam strains are 10−410^{-4} to 10−310^{-3}: solid metals under working loads deform by less than a tenth of a percent — invisible to the eye, which is why wires "feel" rigid. For shear, the force is applied parallel to a face of area AA: shearing stress =F∥/A= F_{\parallel}/A, and shearing strain is the small tilt angle θ≈Δx/h\theta \approx \Delta x/h (displacement of the sheared face over the height between faces). For hydraulic loading, the stress is just the pressure PP, and the volume strain is ΔV/V\Delta V/V. Keep the table:

loading stylestressstrainwhat changes
tensile / compressiveF⊥/AF_\perp/AΔL/L\Delta L / Llength
shearingF∥/AF_\parallel/Aθ≈Δx/h\theta \approx \Delta x/hshape (angles)
hydraulic (volume)PPΔV/V\Delta V/Vvolume

With the per-unit variables built, Hooke's discovery takes its modern, material-level form. For small deformations,

σ=E ε(3)\sigma = E\,\varepsilon \qquad (3)

where: EE — the modulus of elasticity for that loading style (Young's modulus YY for stretching — the star of the next article; shear and bulk moduli for the other two styles). Because ε\varepsilon is dimensionless, EE carries the units of stress, Pa. Read the equation as a stiffness rating: at the same strain, steel (Y≈2×1011Y \approx 2\times10^{11} Pa) develops about 10510^5 times the stress of rubber (∼106\sim 10^6 Pa) — steel fights back harder per unit of deformation. Hooke's law is not a law of nature like Newton's laws; it is an approximation valid for small strains, and the stress–strain curve below shows exactly where it expires.

Derivation AFrom the material law to the spring law — the stiffness of a wire

We derive the spring constant kk of a uniform wire (length LL, cross-section AA, Young's modulus YY) from the material form of Hooke's law, σ=Yε\sigma = Y\varepsilon. The goal is the bridge between this chapter and the spring force F=−kxF = -kx you used all through mechanics: the spring version is the material version with geometry glued back in. The strategy is direct substitution of the definitions of stress and strain, then pattern-matching against F=kxF = kx. Watch how LL and AA enter — their positions explain, at a glance, why long thin wires are floppy and short fat ones are stiff.

Step 1. Write the material law for a wire stretched by xx under an applied force FF (in equilibrium, the internal restoring force matches FF):

FA=Y xL\frac{F}{A} = Y\,\frac{x}{L}

Step 2. Solve for the force:

F=(YAL)xF = \left(\frac{YA}{L}\right) x

Why: everything in the bracket is a constant of the wire — material (YY) times geometry (A/LA/L). Force proportional to extension is exactly Hooke's spring law.

Step 3. Read off the spring constant:

k=YALk = \frac{YA}{L}

Why this settles the "is steel stiff?" puzzle: YY belongs to steel; kk belongs to a particular steel part. Doubling the length halves kk (a longer wire is a softer spring — same stress but more millimetres of stretch per unit strain); doubling the area doubles kk (more lanes carry the load). *Verified: units — [YA/L]=Pa⋅m2/m=N/m[YA/L] = \mathrm{Pa \cdot m^2 / m} = \mathrm{N/m} ✓. Numbers — a steel wire with L=2 mL = 2\ \mathrm{m}, A=1 mm2=10−6 m2A = 1\ \mathrm{mm^2} = 10^{-6}\ \mathrm{m^2}, Y=2×1011Y = 2\times10^{11} Pa gives k=105 N/mk = 10^5\ \mathrm{N/m}: hanging 10 kg (98 N) stretches it x=F/k≈1x = F/k \approx 1 mm, matching worked example 1 below. Standard result: NCERT Ch. 8, HC Verma Ch. 14.*

This one result is worth memorizing with its shape, not just its symbols: k=YA/Lk = YA/L. It converts every spring-chapter skill you own into elasticity-chapter currency — wires in series and parallel, energy stored, oscillations on a wire — all of it returns in the Stretched Wire archetype.

The stress–strain curve: a material's fingerprint

Put a metal sample in a testing machine, pull slowly until it breaks, and plot stress against strain. The resulting curve is the material's mechanical biography, and its labelled landmarks are permanent members of the JEE/NEET question bank.

Figure
The stress–strain curve for a ductile metal — every labelled point is exam material
strain ε stress σ A: proportional limit straight line ends B: elastic limit / yield point last point of full recovery D: ultimate tensile strength highest stress it can take E: fracture Hooke's law valid plastic region: permanent deformation (atoms slip) B→D wide: ductile (steel, copper) B≈E close: brittle (glass, cast iron) Slope of the straight part = Young's modulus Y (next article)

Walk the curve left to right. From the origin to the proportional limit (A), stress and strain climb together in a straight line — this is Hooke's law's entire kingdom, and the slope of this line is the modulus. Between A and the elastic limit or yield point (B), the curve bends: stress and strain are no longer proportional, but the material still snaps back completely when unloaded — elastic, just not linear. Beyond B the character changes: atoms slide into new positions, and unloading leaves a permanent set — the sample returns along a different path and stays deformed. That is the plastic region. The stress peaks at the ultimate tensile strength (D) — the biggest load per area the material can ever carry — after which the sample begins to thin ("necking") and the curve droops to fracture (E). Two vocabulary words classify materials by the width of the plastic region. Ductile materials (steel, copper, aluminium) have a long B-to-E run: they yield, stretch, warn you, and only then break — which is why they can be drawn into wires and why bridges are made of them. Brittle materials (glass, cast iron, chalk) break almost as soon as they leave the straight line: no warning, no plastic buffer. And elastomers (rubber, the aorta's wall tissue) are the curve's rebels: they stretch to strains of 5 or more and return, but their curve is never straight — elastic without obeying Hooke's law, a favourite trick-question fact.

Limiting cases

caseresultmeaning
ε≲10−3\varepsilon \lesssim 10^{-3} (working loads)σ=Eε\sigma = E\varepsilon holdsHooke's kingdom: all of this chapter's formulas apply
stress past the yield pointpermanent set on unloadingpaper-clip physics: the object keeps the new shape
stress →\to ultimate strengthnecking, then fracturethe design ceiling; engineers stay a safety factor below
same FF, area doubledσ\sigma halved, ε\varepsilon halvedthick parts are safe parts — load per lane drops
same σ\sigma, any size objectsame ε\varepsilonstress–strain talk is size-free: that is the whole point
rubber at large strainelastic but non-linearelastic ≠ Hookean: proportionality is the stronger claim

Worked examples

1 · Board level — stress, strain and extension of a loaded wire (CBSE/ISC pattern, 3 marks)

A structural steel wire of length 2.0 m2.0\ \mathrm{m} and cross-sectional area 1.0 mm21.0\ \mathrm{mm^2} hangs vertically. A mass of 10 kg10\ \mathrm{kg} is suspended from its end. Find the stress, the strain, and the elongation. Young's modulus of steel =2.0×1011 Pa= 2.0\times10^{11}\ \mathrm{Pa}; g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\ \mathrm{m/s^2}; neglect the wire's own weight.

Step 1. Convert the area first — the classic mark-loser: A=1.0 mm2=1.0×10−6 m2A = 1.0\ \mathrm{mm^2} = 1.0\times10^{-6}\ \mathrm{m^2}.

Step 2. Stress: the load is F=mg=10×9.8=98 NF = mg = 10 \times 9.8 = 98\ \mathrm{N}, so σ=F/A=98/10−6=9.8×107 Pa\sigma = F/A = 98/10^{-6} = \boxed{9.8\times10^{7}\ \mathrm{Pa}} — 98 MPa, comfortably below steel's yield (~250 MPa): the wire is safe.

Step 3. Strain from Hooke's law: ε=σ/Y=9.8×1072.0×1011=4.9×10−4\varepsilon = \sigma/Y = \dfrac{9.8\times10^7}{2.0\times10^{11}} = \boxed{4.9\times10^{-4}} — about 0.05%, dimensionless, no units to write.

Step 4. Elongation: ΔL=εL=4.9×10−4×2.0=9.8×10−4 m=0.98 mm\Delta L = \varepsilon L = 4.9\times10^{-4} \times 2.0 = 9.8\times10^{-4}\ \mathrm{m} = \boxed{0.98\ \mathrm{mm}}. A two-metre steel wire under a 10 kg load stretches less than a millimetre — that is what a modulus of 101110^{11} Pa feels like.

2 · Competitive level — scaling with geometry (JEE-Main pattern, ~90 seconds)

Wire 1 stretches by 1.0 mm1.0\ \mathrm{mm} under a load WW. Wire 2 is of the same material but twice the length and twice the diameter. What is its extension under the same load WW?

Step 1. Build the extension formula once from σ=Yε\sigma = Y\varepsilon: ΔL=FLAY\Delta L = \dfrac{FL}{AY}. Under fixed FF and fixed material, ΔL∝LA∝Ld2\Delta L \propto \dfrac{L}{A} \propto \dfrac{L}{d^2}.

Step 2. Apply the ratios: L→2LL \to 2L multiplies the extension by 2; d→2dd \to 2d multiplies the area by 4, dividing the extension by 4.

Step 3. Net factor =2/4=1/2= 2/4 = 1/2, so ΔL2=0.5 mm\Delta L_2 = \boxed{0.5\ \mathrm{mm}}. Timing note: never recompute stresses in a scaling question — write ΔL∝L/d2\Delta L \propto L/d^2 and multiply factors; this is a 30-second problem dressed as a 3-minute one. Watch the diameter–radius trap: doubling the diameter doubles the radius too, so area goes up 4×, not 2× or 16×.

3 · Competitive level — reading the curve (NEET pattern, ~60 seconds)

The stress–strain graphs of materials P and Q, drawn on the same axes, are both straight lines up to their proportional limits. P's line is steeper; Q's line extends much farther before fracture, while P fractures just past its yield. (a) Which material has the larger Young's modulus? (b) Which is more ductile? (c) Which is stronger, if Q's fracture occurs at a higher stress value than P's?

Step 1. (a) The slope of the straight region is the modulus, σ/ε\sigma/\varepsilon. Steeper line → larger modulus: P\boxed{P}.

Step 2. (b) Ductility is the length of the run between yield and fracture. P breaks just past yield (brittle); Q keeps deforming plastically: Q\boxed{Q} is more ductile.

Step 3. (c) "Strength" in curve language means the maximum stress reached. Given Q fractures at the higher stress, Q\boxed{Q} is stronger — despite being less stiff. Stiff, strong, and ductile are three independent virtues; conflating them is the question's whole trap. Timing note: for any curve MCQ, decode the three words first — stiffness = slope, strength = height of the peak, ductility = horizontal run after yield. Then read the graph. Sixty seconds includes checking axes aren't swapped (a strain–stress plot inverts every conclusion).

Exam traps

mm² → m² is a factor of 10−610^{-6}, not 10−310^{-3}. The single most common elasticity error. 1 mm2=(10−3 m)2=10−6 m21\ \mathrm{mm^2} = (10^{-3}\ \mathrm{m})^2 = 10^{-6}\ \mathrm{m^2}. Get this wrong and your stress is off by a thousand — usually flagged by a modulus-sized stress or a metre-sized extension. Sanity band: exam stresses land between 10610^6 and 10910^9 Pa.

Diameter given, radius needed. Questions quote diameter ("a wire of diameter 2 mm"); A=πd2/4=πr2A = \pi d^2/4 = \pi r^2. Halve before squaring. In ratio problems, remember A∝d2A \propto d^2, so doubling diameter quarters the extension.

Strain with units. Writing ε=4.9×10−4 m\varepsilon = 4.9\times10^{-4}\ \mathrm{m} costs the answer mark on boards. Strain is a ratio of lengths — a pure number (or a percentage).

LL is the original length, ΔL\Delta L the change. In "a 2 m wire stretches to 2.001 m", the strain is 0.001/20.001/2, not 0.001/2.0010.001/2.001 and not 2.001/22.001/2. Slow down on the subtraction.

Elastic limit ≠ proportional limit ≠ yield of the same number. See the pitfall box: proportionality dies first, elasticity a little later. Assertion–reason and statement-I/II formats exploit exactly this gap.

Stress is not the applied force, and not pressure. Two wires with the same load carry different stresses if their areas differ; and unlike fluid pressure, stress has a style (tensile/shear) and lives inside the solid. If a question mixes "pressure applied to a wire's end" with "stress", translate carefully: numerically equal here, conceptually distinct.

Which gg? CBSE/ISC: 9.8 m/s29.8\ \mathrm{m/s^2} unless stated. JEE-Main/NEET: almost always "take g=10g = 10" — obey the paper, never mix values mid-solution. A-Level: 9.819.81.

Elastic ≠ obeys Hooke's law. Rubber recovers from 500% strain (elastic) with a thoroughly curved graph (non-Hookean). The converse trap: within the straight region every material is both.

Origins · 1 minRobert Hooke and how this was discovered
RH
Robert Hooke
1635–1703 · Gresham College, London

Robert Hooke was seventeenth-century England's great experimental all-rounder: curator of experiments at the Royal Society, surveyor who re-mapped London after the Great Fire, microscopist whose Micrographia (1665) coined the word "cell". In 1676 he hid his elasticity law inside the anagram ceiiinosssttuv, unscrambling it in 1678 as ut tensio, sic vis — "as the extension, so the force" — backed by experiments on springs, wires and coiled watch-springs (his spring-regulated watch nearly beat Huygens to the patent). He never wrote stress or strain — those per-unit refinements came 150 years later with Cauchy and Young — but the proportionality he measured is still the first line of every materials-science course. A bitter rivalry with Newton over optics and gravity left him with no surviving authenticated portrait.

History
1660
— Hooke, aged 25, discovers the proportionality of force and extension while experimenting with springs for watch regulators.
1676
— He publishes the law as the anagram "ceiiinosssttuv" to timestamp the discovery without revealing it.
1678
— The solution appears in De Potentia Restitutiva: "ut tensio, sic vis", with supporting experiments on springs and wires.
1807
— Thomas Young recasts elasticity per unit area and length, making the constant a material property — the modulus.
1822
— Augustin-Louis Cauchy defines stress and strain in full mathematical generality, founding continuum mechanics.
1950
s — Standardized tensile-testing machines make the stress–strain curve the universal certificate of every engineering material.

Going further

Texts. NCERT Physics Class 11, Ch. 8 (Mechanical Properties of Solids) · HC Verma, Concepts of Physics Vol. 1, Ch. 14 · Resnick–Halliday–Walker, Ch. 12 (Equilibrium and Elasticity).

Provenance. All results are standard. A verifier should recompute: k=YA/L=105k = YA/L = 10^5 N/m for the 2 m/1 mm² steel wire; example 1's σ=9.8×107\sigma = 9.8\times10^7 Pa, ε=4.9×10−4\varepsilon = 4.9\times10^{-4}, ΔL=0.98\Delta L = 0.98 mm; example 2's factor 2/4=1/2⇒0.52/4 = 1/2 \Rightarrow 0.5 mm.

Prerequisites. Spring Force & Hooke's Law · Equilibrium of Concurrent Forces. Leads to. Young's, Bulk & Shear Moduli · The Stretched Wire (archetype).

Is stress the same thing as pressure? Both are N/m².

Same unit, different physics. Pressure is a scalar squeeze that a fluid applies equally in all directions on any surface. Stress lives inside a solid, describes the internal restoring forces across a chosen cross-section, and comes in styles — tensile, compressive, shear — with directions attached. Hydraulic stress (a solid squeezed by fluid on all sides) is the one case where the stress really is just the pressure. If an exam asks for "stress" in a stretched wire, it always means F/AF/A across the wire's cross-section.

Why do we bother with stress and strain instead of just force and extension?

Because force and extension describe an object, while stress and strain describe the material. A 1 N pull stretches a long thin wire a lot and a short fat rod imperceptibly — same material, different geometry. Dividing out area and original length removes the geometry: any two steel samples at the same stress have the same strain, whether paper clip or bridge cable. That is what lets a single tested number (the modulus) predict the behaviour of every steel part ever manufactured.

If a solid is just atoms connected by bond-springs, why does Hooke's law ever fail?

Because a real interatomic force curve is only approximately linear near its equilibrium spacing. Small stretches sample the linear part — Hooke's kingdom. Pull harder and the curve's true non-linearity shows up (the bend after the proportional limit); pull harder still and atoms don't just stretch their bonds, they slip past one another into new lattice positions. Slipping is not reversible — release the load and the atoms stay put. That is plastic deformation, and no spring picture describes it.

What exactly happens when I bend a paper clip and it stays bent?

You drove the metal past its yield point. In the bent region, layers of atoms slid over each other (dislocations moved, in materials-science language) and re-settled into new positions. Unloading recovers only the small elastic part of the deformation; the slipped part is permanent. Bonus fact you can feel: bending it back and forth repeatedly makes the clip warm (plastic work becomes heat) and eventually snaps it — repeated plastic cycles accumulate damage, which is the same fatigue mechanism aircraft inspectors hunt for.

Is a stiffer material always a stronger material?

No — and this distinction is a reliable MCQ. Stiffness is the modulus (slope of the straight region): how much stress per unit strain. Strength is the ultimate tensile stress (height of the curve's peak): how much stress before failure begins. Glass is stiffer than many plastics but far weaker in practice; some steels are equally stiff (same YY — it barely varies across steels) yet differ hugely in strength. Stiff, strong, ductile: three separate columns on the material's report card.

Does Hooke's law for solids have anything to do with F = −kx for springs?

It is that law, seen at the material level. Apply σ=Yε\sigma = Y\varepsilon to a specific wire and you get F=(YA/L)xF = (YA/L)x — a spring law with k=YA/Lk = YA/L. A coiled spring is just a clever geometry that converts wire-twisting into large axial motion, giving a small, useful kk from a very stiff material. The spring article (Hooke's law for springs) owns the force law and combinations; this chapter owns where kk comes from.

Why do exam questions say "neglect the weight of the wire"? When can't we?

With only an end load, every cross-section carries the same force, so one stress describes the whole wire. Include the wire's own weight and lower sections carry only the load below them, while the top section carries load plus the entire wire — stress now varies along the wire, maximum at the support. That version appears as a JEE-Advanced variant (elongation under self-weight = ρgL2/2Y\rho g L^2/2Y, computed by integration or the "half-weight at the end" shortcut) — it lives in the Stretched Wire archetype.

Steel and rubber: which is "more elastic"? My textbook says steel and my intuition says rubber.

Physics vocabulary and street vocabulary disagree. In physics, "more elastic" means resists deformation more and recovers more forcefully — a larger modulus. Steel at 2×10112\times10^{11} Pa beats rubber at ∼106\sim10^6 Pa by a factor of a hundred thousand, so steel is more elastic. Street usage means "stretches a lot", which is the opposite property (low modulus, large recoverable strain). Boards love this: "Which is more elastic, steel or rubber? Justify." Answer steel, cite the modulus, collect the marks.

Before this

Where this leads